Skip to content

How The U.S. Failed To Meet the China Challenge – WSJ Opinion

Opinion – Robert D, Blackwell and Richard Fontaine

The authors of the presented content, Richard Fontaine and Robert Blackwill, are foreign policy commentators who co-authored a book titled “Lost Decade: The US Pivot to Asia and the Rise of Chinese Power.” Both authors have significant experience and expertise in foreign policy and international affairs:

  • Robert Blackwill served in the George W. Bush administration as the ambassador to India and held positions on the National Security Council. He also has a background in diplomacy and foreign policy.
  • Richard Fontaine is the CEO of the Center for a New American Security and has previously worked as a foreign policy adviser to Senator John McCain.

What are their opinions?

  1. China as the greatest strategic challenge: Both Democratic and Republican administrations agree that China is the most significant strategic challenge the U.S. faces, but actions taken have been insufficient.

2. Historical context of U.S. policy: Since the end of the Cold War, U.S. focus shifted from Europe to the Middle East due to various conflicts, delaying a proper response to China’s rise.

3. The pivot to Asia: Initiated by Obama in 2011 and continued by Trump and Biden, this policy aimed to shift U.S. focus and resources towards the Asia-Pacific, but has been inadequately implemented.

4. Resource allocation and diplomatic efforts: The U.S. has struggled with consistent resource allocation and diplomatic focus due to other global conflicts, such as those in the Middle East and Europe.

5. Recommendations for U.S. policy: The authors argue for a significant increase in defense budgets, redeployment of military resources to Asia, strengthening alliances, and clear communication with China regarding Taiwan to effectively counter China’s growing influence.

Given the current US sentiments on China, it is highly unrealistic to wish for better bilateral relations any time soon!